Cooking a turkey is a personal thing. My Mom made a wonderful stuffed turkey that family would come 150 miles to have in a day. (Besides her Giblet Gravy and mashed potatoes!) I tried the getting up at 5:30 to stuff and put the turkey on and found that sucked a big one! My method for the past ten years has been “Paper Bag Turkey”. It is easy, it is fast cooking for a turkey, it turns out golden and wonderful, and it is moist and flavorful. Stuffing on the side and giblet gravy is a snap! (NO four days for me!) I make a turkey at least three times a year. I like a BBQ’d turkey also….but that’s another story!
Paper Bag Turkey
1 TURKEY, no more than 10-12 POUNDS (I like the fresh, free range ones)
1 tsp freshly ground black pepper
2 tsp sea salt
2 tsp hungarian paprika
4 tsp hot water
1 cup + good peanut oil (I like the peanut oil from an Asian Grocery, it has so much more flavor)
1 yellow onion cut in half
plain brown large PAPER grocery bag
stapler
Heat oven to 325 degrees
Combine pepper, salt, paprika and hot water. Mix and let stand at least 10 minutes. Add peanut oil to make 1 C of mixture and mix again. Take the giblets and neck out of the turkey. Wash and dry turkey. Rub peanut oil mixture inside and outside turkey( and under the skin on the breast and thighs). Add both onion halves inside the turkey cavities. Truss turkey legs and cavities. Meanwhile pour balance of peanut oil inside brown paper grocery bag. Rub oil into every pore of every inch of the inside and outside of the bag. Place turkey in the sack, breast up. Fold over the end of the sack and staple securely. Place on a baking sheet with a lip ( I use a large, oval roasting pan to catch the drips) and place in a 325 oven for approximately 10 minutes per pound plus 15 minutes overall. The turkey is cooked by live steam, so, when the sack is opened, BE CAREFUL! The turkey is self browning and self basting. Putting it in a pan is a good thing as the bag may leak juices which you can put in the gravy or on the dressing.
DO NOT SUBSTITUTE ANY OTHER OIL FOR THE PEANUT OIL! ONLY COOK THE BIRD IN A PLAIN BROWN PAPER SACK STAPLED SHUT!
You can roast the turkey bones in a pan at about 400 degrees for about 45 minutes and then put in a soup pot, cover with hot water and add onion, celery and carrot and boil, turn down and simmer 8-12 hours. Make soup or put in baggies by 2 cup increments and in freezer trays and freeze for use later. It smells so good on the stove!
10 Comments
Okay, so is peanut oil the secret to cooking in a brown paper bag?
My mom was a whiz at giblet gravy – actually, at all gravies. And roasting the bones before making stock is an old trick I’ve heard NObody mention in years!
Thanks, Scotia!
Biscuit,
Peanut oil is the secret to paper bag turkey. AND the best peanut oil you can get. That used to be Planters, now it is an Asian brand, Lion & Globe, that seems to have a better and stronger peanut flavor. I’m not saying it is too strong to cook with, just that it is better than other domestic brands.
Man, my stock is simmering now and smells divine! :dots:
God, I’m going to do this!
I’m going to try it with a nice chicken, though …
Actually, the other thing I do when cooking stock, is about halfway through cooking, I take out the long bones and crack them with a hammer covered with a baggie and then put them back in the stock to cook till the end. Adds a lot of flavor.
I’ve heard of that, too! But long, long ago …
Great tips for stock, Scotia!
Sounds delicious. No oven and I have not seen any peanut oil here. I am going to look for a convection oven next time I go to the city. How can folks live without an oven? I have a nice toaster oven but really, it just cannot handle more than half a turkey breast.
What kind of oven, do you know?
I have no idea. They sell these little gas ovens here but they have four burners on the top. I do not need the burners. I hate to buy a new stove with an oven while renting.
Most of the time the simple things are the hardest way to go.
How funny – I’m just the opposite. I want the burners but use the ovens rarely.
No live-blogging today – I have to write exams and I want everyone to enjoy Scotia’s diary.
You must be logged in to post a comment.